Deck the halls with decadence over the holidays. These treats feature two handcrafted culinary treasures: specialty cheeses and chocolates. Cheese expert Austin Coe Butler shares advice on pairing them and four indulgences ideal for gift-giving, cookie platters or when savory-sweet cravings come calling this season.
By Austin Coe Butler
Austin is a cheesemaker, cheesemonger, buyer and educator at France 44 Cheese Shop in Minneapolis. What he loves most about his work is connecting people with their food, where stories and flavors meet in personal memories and the fascinating history of cheese.
Why do chocolate and cheese pair so well?
Cheese and chocolate share a natural affinity as fermented foods. They also share similar textures and flavors: creamy, nutty, salty, tangy and sometimes funky. One common pitfall in pairing them is drawing out bitterness. For example, the sharpness in a cheddar or the tanginess of a blue can slip into bitterness when paired with darker, tannic chocolate. So, when pairing, I start with milder milk chocolates and work toward stronger flavors.
What are some tips for pairing them?
When I pair cheese and chocolate together, I often think of other moments when savory and sweet elements combine—ice cream sprinkled with sea salt, chocolate and chiles, sugar cured bacon–and depart from there. I also like to invest in quality crafted chocolates and cheeses, such as those from “bean-to-bar” chocolate producers and
Wisconsin’s cheesemakers.
Bringing Out The Best of Both
Austin shares four favorite pairings below.
1. Henning’s Chipotle Cheddar + Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate Hazelnut 55% Milk Chocolate + Bacon + Maple Syrup
This might be my favorite pairing: the smoky chipotles, smoldering spice, and cheddar zip from the cheese melting with roasted Oregon hazelnuts and milk chocolate made with earthy Brazilian cacao remind me of a rich and complex mole poblano.
2. Marieke® Gouda Aged (Aged 9-12 Months) + Mānoa Chocolate Hawai’i Island Kealakekua 70% Dark Chocolate + Shortbread Cookies + Candied Pecans + Caramel Sauce + Sugared Rosemary
Marieke's aged gouda is nutty, robust, and salty and pairs perfectly with dark chocolate. What I love about this pairing is that the flavors blend, creating a new taste you’d expect to find in chocolate ice cream drizzled with salted caramel.
3. Roth Buttermilk Blue® + French Broad Malted 45% Milk Chocolate
There’s something magical about this pairing. Tangy, salty Roth Buttermilk Blue® and sweet, malted milk chocolate are an especially fun combo. The taste is like dipping a French fry into a milkshake. While this is a milder cheese, bigger, bolder blues can be rounded out nicely with sweetness.
Make it: Roth Buttermilk Blue® Chocolate Cups
4. BelGioioso American Grana® + Fossa Harana Philippines 64% Dark Milk Chocolate
Simply indulgent! Italian-inspired grana cheese meets a fruity dark milk chocolate. The intense umami and sweetness of cooked milk in this nutty, hard cheese are matched by smooth, creamy chocolate with notes of yogurt, grape candy, and ripened bananas.
Make it: American Grana® and Dark Milk Chocolate Bark